The AI efficiency trap: When a leaner team becomes a weaker business

AI is already changing the workforce. Just maybe not in the way everyone expected.

We’re not seeing entire teams disappear overnight. We’re seeing fewer people being asked to do more.

Product managers are prototyping. Engineers are moving from brief to production. Marketing and GTM teams are building automated workflows that would once have passed through several people.

Job descriptions are stretching too. Businesses want people who can work across functions, make decisions with less direction and take something from idea to outcome without five handovers along the way.

On paper, it sounds great. Smaller team. Faster decisions. More output.

But at what point does a lean team just become an understaffed one?

 

One person is being asked to own a lot more

Between May and July 2026, Onset’s FY26/27 Hiring & Salary Insights Survey gathered views from professionals across technology, product, data, AI, GTM and leadership. The findings offer a directional snapshot, supported by the conversations we’re having across the market.

One theme kept coming up: AI is reducing the number of people businesses think they need, rather than creating new roles.

Respondents described businesses trying to maintain, or even increase, output with fewer people. One put it pretty bluntly: a business can operate “permanently understaffed” if the people left are strong enough.

That’s where the efficiency story gets more complicated.

There’s nothing wrong with hiring people who can have a bigger impact. The problem starts when “high impact” quietly becomes shorthand for one person doing what used to be three jobs.

That creates three risks worth paying attention to.

 

1. When too much depends on too few people

Imagine one person knows the customer context, the technical logic, the AI workflows and all the weird little things nobody thought to document.

They might be incredibly productive. They’re also a pretty big single point of failure.

If they leave or burn out, you’re not simply replacing one employee. You’re trying to piece together an entire way of working that lived mostly in their head.

Retention could become a problem too.

In our survey, 26% of respondents rated their salary satisfaction at four out of ten or below. Another 32% gave it a five or six.

That doesn’t mean they’re all job hunting. But if someone’s role has quietly doubled while their salary, title or recognition hasn’t moved with it, another offer can start looking pretty interesting.

If your new team dynamic only works while a handful of your best people are running at 100%, it probably isn’t as lean as it looks.

It’s fragile.

 

2. AI use is moving faster than the rules

Among the regular AI users who responded, 51% said they were already using tools their employer didn’t provide.

When we asked which skills were becoming more valuable in their field, AI fluency appeared in more than 80% of responses across every function represented.

The survey doesn’t tell us every business is in the same position. It does suggest employees may be adopting AI faster than their organisations are setting clear rules around it.

People weren’t just talking about prompting. What mattered was knowing how to apply AI: building workflows, checking outputs and understanding the risks.

Because the question isn’t really whether employees should be using AI.

They already are.

The more useful questions are: does the business know what tools people are using? What information is going into them? Who is checking the output? And if an automated workflow gets something wrong, who owns that mistake?

And as AI moves beyond simple prompts and starts researching, communicating and acting across several steps, those questions become a lot more important.

Being good at AI is useful.

Being good at AI without knowing how to check it can create a whole new category of problems.

 

3. We could be creating efficiency now and creating a talent problem later

The current market has made it easier for employers to ask for more experience at almost every level. You can understand why.

If an experienced person is available, why take a chance on someone who still needs developing?

The problem is what happens if everyone thinks that way.

Junior work does two things. It gets work done, but it also gives people the experience they need to become good at their jobs.

AI can take away some of that early work. It can’t magically create experienced people five years from now.

If businesses stop hiring and developing junior talent, the need for senior people doesn’t disappear. The path that creates those senior people does.

The businesses that keep investing in emerging talent could end up with something increasingly hard to find: people who actually understand the fundamentals of their profession and know when, where and how to use AI on top of them.

 

Don’t hire the unicorn. Build the right environment.

The hiring briefs are getting ambitious.

AI skills. Commercial judgment. Technical knowledge. Great communicator. Strategic thinker. Hands-on executor. Cross-functional. Ten years’ experience.

And, naturally, within budget.

There’s a point where a “high-impact hire” becomes one person compensating for everything missing around them.

AI will let smaller teams do more. Roles will get broader. Some work that once needed several people won’t anymore.

But fewer people shouldn’t automatically be the goal.

If the trade-off is exhausted high performers, important knowledge held by one person, AI tools nobody is tracking and fewer chances for people to learn their craft, the cost hasn’t disappeared.

It’s just moved somewhere less obvious.

That’s capability debt.

And eventually, someone has to pay it back.

 

Conclusion

Across Onset and The Omnia Collective, we help businesses work out where AI can genuinely improve the work, what should still sit with people and which skills their teams will need next. We see both sides: the people businesses are hiring, and the AI, data and technology changing how teams work. That helps leaders decide where AI adds value, where the risks sit and how to build a leaner team without becoming too dependent on a few people. If your business is working through this shift, that’s exactly the kind of conversation we’re having with teams right now.

For more insights into the forces shaping hiring, salaries and teams, download our FY26/27 Hiring & Salary Guide here.

What our clients say

“Ronny & the Onset Group helped us scale our team in the early stages of our growth, finding a number of talented engineering candidates to join our Development team. The Onset Group are highly professional and a pleasure to work with.”

Georgia Punch
HR & Operations

“We have been working with the Onset Group for the past few years, helping us secure both contract and permanent staff across multiple technical areas. They always ensure they have our business’ needs in mind and it’s great working with a partner that truly understands the technical space that we are in. Of all of the recruiters I have met or worked with over the years, I couldn’t recommend this group any more.”

Paul Madani
Head of Data and Technology

“IPG Mediabrands have built a solid, trusting working relationship with the Onset Group over the past few years. We are very selective on who we partner with regarding our recruitment needs. The Onset Group have proven time and time again, they absolutely deserve a spot on our PSA. They understand our business, they deliver, they follow up, they’re smart and they are professional.”

Lisa Gray
Head of Human Resources

“I’ve worked in the product community in Sydney for just 3 years and the Onset are my go-to folk for product talent (and opportunities). Once in my role I worked with the team at Onset to build out my product team of 6 over the next year. So I’ve experienced the quality and expertise from both sides of the engagement.”

Jennifer Flynn
Group Manager, Product Management

“Working with The Onset was fantastic. They spent the time with me up front on understanding not only the requirements of the role but also the qualities and skill sets needed to fill the role well. The candidates provided were really strong and led to hires who have not only helped us fill roles but also enhance our overall company culture by introducing us to top quality candidates. Thanks Onset!”

Yaniv Klein
Product Director

“We partnered with The Onset, a leading IT recruitment agency, explained the journey we were on, and asked them to sell our vision to the Sydney market in our search for high quality developers. It was important that the people we chose not only had high technical skills but were a good cultural fit and understood where oOh! was going”

Andy Mcquarrie
Chief Technology Officer

“…by taking time to understand our unique hiring requirements, both from the start and as our needs have evolved. At Digital Asset, we’re looking for engineers and product managers with a specialized mix of skills and industry experience, for example, a strong background in financial services, or knowledge of functional programming languages. Onset has helped us find experienced candidates who are not only highly qualified but also inspired to work with a firm like ours”

Drew Harding
Senior Delivery Manager

“In addition to running the search and recruitment process they helped us to shape the role and were able to guide us through what was happening in the market and the experiences of other high growth companies.”

Rachel Debeck
Chief Operating Officer

“It was a pleasure working with Danielle to source a full stack developer for our company. She put real effort into understanding what we were looking for and helped us find the right candidate. Plus helped us find the first female developer!”

Antony Francis
Team Lead

“Onset has been partnering with Haventec for over three years. The team at Onset have the great ability to connect with our team and understand our business and culture to be able to place employees that fit our team like a glove. It takes great talent to recognise the unique needs of each business and to be able to deliver on them so well”

Edora David
Business Operations Manager

Our Clients

Leading Businesses Connect with the Best Talent, 
with The Onset

Let's work together

Ready to connect with the best recruiters in the industry? (you know you want to)